Forums › Kitchen DIY Forum › Kitchen DIY Advice › Askilan worktop
This topic has 4 voices, contains 19 replies.
| Author | Posts |
|---|---|
| Author | Posts |
| April 30, 2005 at 10:07 am #5879 | |
|
elainelib |
Hi I am in the process of choosing a new kitchen (what a nightmare !) and obviously I am drawn to all the more expensive units and worktops . Although I really like the granite worktops I have seen , one kitchen supplier has suggested Askilan worktops as they are quite a bit cheaper than granite but better quality than laminate I was wondering if anyone has experience good or bad with this worktop and how it equates with other surfaces Many thanks Elaine |
| May 4, 2005 at 5:34 pm #5880 | |
|
elainelib |
Does no-one know anything about Askilan then ? !! |
| May 4, 2005 at 6:34 pm #5881 | |
|
tkd2005 |
Hi elainelib, I used to work for John Lewis in London, and they sold Askilan. I didnt use it an awful lot, but know that it is a reasonable product to work with. This type of worktop is sometimes sold as having the same properties as say Corian or Schock, but isn’t really. It, like Corian & Schock is made from something like quartz and a resin, basically stone resin mix. I suspect the quality of materials used in Corian betters that of Askilan. Corian and schock are much thicker when used as worktops. From what i can remember, Askilan consists of a few millimeters of material, say 2-3mm, on a fibre glass/lightweight base. Having a thin layer doesn’t mean it wont last, but there are limitations with what you can do with the worktops, i.e. drainer grooves and the likes. I also remember that Askilan had depth limitations, and it could only come 600mm depth, anything beyond for normal worktop would have an inconspicuous join, but this may have changed now. There are a number of worksurfaces out there that use the same idea as Askilan, i.e thin surface on lightweight base, but i would say askilan is one of the better ones. Some are even sprayed on!! At least Askilan uses sheet material, not a spray! I hope thats of some help to you, sorry if its a bit patchy in places! tkd2005 |
| May 5, 2005 at 9:56 am #5883 | |
|
elainelib |
Many thanks for your reply , It is actually John Lewis kitchens that I am looking at ! Obviously it is going to be a bit pricey as they would have to fit it as well ….. so I was wondering whether to go for slightly cheaper units and say , granite worktop or the expensive units and the Askilan worktop ….. or I could just win the lottery ! I was hoping to have the drainer grooves , too …… I am going there tonight to arrange a planning visit – as an ex-employee who is not trying to sell me anything would you recommend their kitchens ? It is the Mezzo range I’m interested in (if that means anything !) Thanks again ps this is such a great site ! Elaine |
| May 5, 2005 at 10:13 am #5884 | |
|
tkd2005 |
What a co-incidence that you’re looking at John Lewis kitchens. Mezzo is a cream gloss kitchen if i remember correctly? I would check with them about the situation with having drainer grooves etc. I know in some instances thicker material can be used in the sink area to allow them to put drainer grooves in. They may also be able to inset a standard sink into the worktop (i.e set in the thickness of the worktops), i have done this before and it looks good, but does depend on flexibilty of the worktop and the supplier! Granite we all know can have drainer grooves put in. You may find though that as granite is glossy, and so is the kitchen, that it may be too overpowering? This is down to personal preference really, and things like how light the room is and how you are going to light the room will affect it. Askilan is a matt finish so this may contrast a bit? I think their own range of kitchens (Jonelle) is a quality range. They used to buy carcases from Mereway who are well known and a good manufacturer. I also know Alno very well (i think they still sell these), and although this is in the upper price brackets, it is a fantastic range of kitchens – the range of units is huge! Overall, JL kitchen ranges are good quality and worth looking at. I too agree, this is a great site, theres nothing else on the net that really comes near it! Its also good that designers, manufacturers, clients etc can all come together and exchange knowledge! If you dont mind me asking, which John Lewis is it you are dealing with? Regards tkd |
| May 5, 2005 at 11:47 am #5885 | |
|
elainelib |
Thanks again for your comments …… I started off looking in the Brent Cross John Lewis – that’s where I saw the Mezzo units (which although called hi-gloss seem quite subtle – unless it’s just the lighting in the shop !) But then I visited High Wycombe which is slightly quicker to get to (less traffic , that’s for sure ….) so that’s who I am dealing with at the moment (Norman someone …) I never realised that choosing a kitchen was such a hassle ! And I have had three different people round who all gave me the same basic design …. when I showed it to the guy in John lewis he thought the plan I had come up with on my own was much better ergonomically – and after all , I’m the one who is going to be working in it ! ho hum ……. ( and why are Neff ovens so dear ? !!!! ) Sorry for rambling …. |
| May 5, 2005 at 12:54 pm #5886 | |
|
tkd2005 |
Hi. No need to apologise! There are so many things to consider when you’re buying a kitchen. It seems like you’ve done some looking around. I think the trouble with a lot of outlets is designers design what they think is right, not what you want or like. As a designer myself, i always listen to the input of the client as i think its vital. The john lewis design service is good. Were the other designs done by independent outlets? Hope you dont mind me asking. I also look after the design service on this website, if you wanted a non biased design then that may be of use to you? As for Neff, i wouldn’t say they were massivley expensive, they are certainly not the cheapest but the quality is very good, after all they are German built! Ive designed with Neff for a while and have heard very few complaints. I think they sit quite comfortably mid-upper market price wise. If you are looking at your new kitchen as an investment, rather than a freshen up for a couple of years, then Neff is a good choice. A trend that i have realsied recently is to spend a little more on the appliances you see, and go for slightly cheaper integrated or ‘hidden’ appliances. This could be another pro for Neff. Hope that can be of some help to you! Have you looked at any other appliances? tkd. |
| May 5, 2005 at 2:43 pm #5887 | |
|
elainelib |
I think the trouble is , I like the expensive stuff ! I never go for the basic model either , so that bumps up the price a little …… Neff’s designs are tip-top and I just think they make any kitchen look really classy – and yes , I’m going for a slightly cheaper semi- integrated d/w but (almost) top-of-the-range double oven ……. As for the designs I’ve had done already , two were independent and Magnet was the other ……… after I have the John Lewis lot round I’ll be on design overload ! One of the independents does the same Mezzo units as JL (Wentworth, I believe) and their fitting price and worktop price will probably be cheaper but I’d never actually heard of them before – how can you tell if someone is going to do a great job or not ? I’m sure the JL fitting service is excellent but rather expensive ….. I’ll have to decide soon , but I have this funny feeling I’ll be going for the expensive units , the granite worktop and the personal loan !! Elaine |
| May 5, 2005 at 7:39 pm #5888 | |
|
tkd2005 |
I suffer from the expensive taste syndrome! Neff’s designs are good, and theyve recently changed most of the range design wise. I have heard of Wentworth, but dont really know an awful lot about them. The best way to find out what sort of job they are going to do is to ask for references, i.e customers who have had a kitchen from them. Most respectable kitchen companies will be willing to co- operate, and most will ask customers if they mind being used as references. Some will also have portfolios in their showrooms, so take a good look through them too. Good luck with deciding which options to go for, it will be interesting to hear which you choose, and also to hear what you think of the JL service once they have been round! I always think if you’re going to do a kitchen its worth doing well and make sure you love it, its a big expense and it’s got to be right for you. Hopefully speak soon, Regards tkd |
| May 20, 2005 at 10:19 am #5905 | |
|
elainelib |
Well , I have just had the John Lewis guy round , and I have to say he’s the first one who actually LOOKED like a designer !! which we both worked on …………. haven’t actually had the quote yet ! thought their fitting was very expensive ……… my kitchen is about 15 ft long with units down both sides but he suggested the fitting may be around £3500 ……… is it me or is that too expensive ? Obviously I want a good job done but surely I don’t have to pay that much – which brings me to my next question – how can you find a fitter who will do an excellent job and not rip you off ? ! Cheers Elaine ! I even dreamt about it the other night , which is rather worrying – I used to have far more interesting dreams !!! |
| May 23, 2005 at 9:49 pm #5908 | |
|
TaraD |
Hi Elaine same kitchen, Mezzo Hi Gloss – it is a super kitchen. I have the same kitchen size and John Lewis quoted around £3000 just for the fitting of the units. On top of that are all the other bits like electricals, plastering etc etc. found a first class kitchen fitter and has your dream kitchen been installed to your entire satisfaction. Were the guys who fitted your kitchen cheaper than John Lewis. elainelib wrote: Well , I have just had the John Lewis |
| May 24, 2005 at 10:13 am #5910 | |
|
elainelib |
Give us a chance !! I’ve only just had the design done !! And if the quote for supply only is still too dear I may have to go elsewhere …….. The other place I’m looking at do Second Nature kitchens , which this site seems to approve of and although they are quite expensive , the fitting quoted was about £1500-2000 which seems much more reasonable ! It is tempting to have the whole lot done by one firm , as I don’t have the time or the knowledge to mess about with different fitters etc etc as soon as I’ve made up my mind I’ll let you know ! By the way , Tara , have you chosen the white or the pergamon ? I thought it was the pergamon I was looking at in the shop but it was terrible lighting and the assistant confirmed it was white ! I rather like the pergamon , but am finding it difficult to choose a granite colour to go with it ! Cheers Elaine |
| May 24, 2005 at 7:48 pm #5913 | |
|
timfoley |
Wow! This is an interesting thread and throws up a number of issues such as fitting standards, designer capabilities worktop preferences and kitchen choice. I have recently been busy filming for a Tonight with Trevor MacDonald programme, (Liverpool House Refurb) the results of which have a dedicated page on the site at http://www.kitchensfitted.co.uk/news/To … Donald.php providing the answers for new members. Thanks to you all. TKD 2005, incidentally, is Mark Hanner, an excellent designer who is pioneering our innovative design consultancy via this site. This is proving a huge success and those of you wishing to obtain professional design with a personal touch in the comfort of your own home look no further than here. http://www.kitchensfitted.co.uk/Consultancy/index.php Fitting costs can vary tremendously and are often reflected by the extent of work to be undertaken but as yet there are still no installer standards so pot luck plays a risky part of the process. Here at TFI we are passionate about developing and participating in a training scheme for the much heralded but much delayed National Training Group for installer standards. I have learned to become less enthusiastic and less confident of the implementation of this scheme after a series of empty promises by those in charge of introducing it. On the many occasions I have been contacted regarding the scheme and the only consistency is the sense of disappointment at a failure and indifference to it’s introduction. Too many meetings and not enough action methinks. Perhaps the dinosaurs prevalent in our industry are digging in for the duration and anyway the wine and food would be too good to miss. Ok I’ve vented my fury on this and will have no choice but to act autonomously to bring about a suitable training scheme to rival the non existent one if the delay continues. To ensure an installers capability at present is difficult and the majority are employed on a sub-contract basis but a number of indicators will help you choose the right person for the job and to determine how take a look here http://www.kitchensfitted.co.uk/ExternalMedia/Start.php This article includes a section on how to choose your installer. Elaine and Tara, welcome and good luck in choosing your new kitchens. Second Nature are an excellent choice as are Wentworth, who incidentally are the retail arm of Mereway who were mentioned earlier in this thread. Askilan is a new one on me but after some research I have discovered it is a European corporation, Arplama, who manufacture it. In addition they make a surface called Sand’Or which is, like Askilan, a quartz based surface yet a greater quartz content. Askilan seems unique for a quartz based surface in that, like Corian, it can be joined virtually seamlessly. This I have to investigate further and will update when I discover more. Sounds like an ideal kitchen surface but I will reserve judgement for the time being. Well I’m sorry to have whittled on a bit but I think everyone may have assumed I’d disappeared off the face of the earth. Tim |
| May 26, 2005 at 7:47 am #5917 | |
|
TaraD |
Hi Elaine for Hi-Gloss Pergamon. The colour is just off-white – very elegant and the carcasses are top class. Am getting contractors to quote and fit the whole lot. Don’t want to mess around with different trades people either. Dark granite or speckled brown with black with a touch of pink would look great and a white hi-gloss tiles floor and voila you have your dream kitchen. Tara |
| May 27, 2005 at 6:50 pm #5919 | |
|
timfoley |
Tara, Just curious but what makes you say that the carcasses are top class. to this decision. High gloss seems to be a popular trend for consumers currently but I have to say it would not be a choice for me. The only high gloss finish I would advocate in the kitchen is the quartz or granite worktops as they are able to withstand the everyday rigours that a kitchen is subject to. Having said that, if you are aware of the additional work required to maintain the finish then they can still look good for years to come and I was surprised to find that, when visiting a client for whom we installed a high gloss kitchen for seven years ago, it looked as good as the day it had been fitted. The proof is in the pudding but it is also testament to the hard work of the client in maintaining the look. Certain laminate worktops in high gloss suffer from what is known as telegraphing which is a flaw of the manufacturing process that shows up as a ripple type effect particularly when subjected to the sun or a light source. I am aware more recently however that the problem hasd been overcome by certain manufacturers. I’m not for a minute, being the harbinger of doom but I think it’s important that people are aware of certain factors before buying their kitchen. The reason for this website and forum is just that. Tim. |
You must be logged in to reply to this topic.







